|
|
||||||||
Corresponding author: Cindy L. Munro, RN, PhD, ANP, Professor, School of Nursing, Virginia Commonwealth University, Box 980567, Richmond, VA 23298-0567 (e-mail: cmunro{at}vcu.edu).
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective To describe the relationship between ventilator-associated pneumonia and oral health status, changes in oral health status during the first 7 days after intubation, and microbial colonization of the oropharynx and trachea.
Methods A total of 66 patients were enrolled within 24 hours of intubation and were followed up for up to 7 days. Data on oral health measures and the Clinical Pulmonary Infection Score (CPIS) were collected at baseline, day 4 (n = 37), and day 7 (n = 21). A regression model was used to predict risk of pneumonia at day 4.
Results Dental plaque and oral organisms increased over time. Correlations were significant for baseline and day 4 dental plaque (P < .001), baseline salivary lactoferrin and day 4 plaque (P = .01), and lower salivary volume and higher day 4 CPIS (P = .02). Potential pathogens were identified in oral cultures for 6 patients before or at the same time as the appearance of the organisms in tracheal aspirates. Correlations were significant with day 4 CPIS for score on the Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation (APACHE) II (P = .007), day 4 salivary volume (P = .02), interaction of APACHE II score and day 1 CPIS (P<.001), and interaction of day 1 CPIS and plaque (P=.01).
Conclusions Higher dental plaque scores confer greater risk for ventilator-associated pneumonia, particularly for patients with greater severity of illness. Salivary volume and lactoferrin may affect the risk.
A major risk factor for VAP is colonization of the oropharynx by potential pathogens such as Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus pneumoniae, and gram-negative rods.811 Several factors contribute to the importance of oral health status in the development of VAP.
Within 48 hours of admission to the intensive care unit (ICU), patients have changes in oral flora to predominantly gram-negative organisms, which include more virulent organisms.12,13 Dental plaque can provide an environment for microorganisms that cause VAP, and dental plaque of patients in the ICU can be colonized by potential respiratory pathogens such as methicillin-resistant S aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa.14 In addition, abnormalities in salivary flow may place patients at risk for overgrowth of organisms in the oropharynx. Circulation of saliva in the mouth provides mechanical removal of debris and plaque, and saliva contains both innate and specific immune components active in controlling oral microorganisms.1518 Thus, salivary volume and amounts of salivary immune components such as lactoferrin and immunoglobulin A may influence oropharyngeal colonization and development of VAP. Tubes traversing the oral cavity that keep the mouth open may contribute to the accumulation of dental plaque by exacerbating xerostomia (dry mouth). Many medications also reduce salivary flow.
| The bacteria found in dental plaque may cause ventilator-associated pneumonia.
|
Oral health status in critically ill adults is an important issue, but it has not been well studied. The specific aim of this study was to describe the relationship between oral health status and the development of VAP. Specifically, we examined the relationship between oral health status, as indicated by assessment of the oral cavity, cultures of oral specimens, salivary volume, and salivary immune components, and development of VAP, as indicated by the Clinical Pulmonary Infection Score (CPIS). In addition, we determined changes in oral health status during the first 7 days of intubation and mechanical ventilation and the relationships between microbial colonization of the oropharynx and colonization of the trachea over time.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
All patients admitted to the unit were reviewed for potential enrollment in the study. Patients receiving mechanical ventilation were enrolled within 24 hours of intubation. Because reintubation increases the risk for VAP,19,20 patients who already had had endotracheal intubation during the current hospital admission were excluded. Data were obtained during a period of up to 7 days or until extubation. Because clinical evidence of VAP occurs after 48 hours of intubation, data on VAP and oral health were collected on days 1 (baseline), 4, and 7.
Measurement and Quantification of Key Variables
Oral Health Status.
Evaluation of oral health status had 5 components:
Assessment of the oral cavity consisted of visually scoring 9 components:
The assessments were documented by using a 100-mm visual analog scale (VAS) for each component. These components were chosen on the basis of previous work21,22 and were developed in conjunction with a dental hygiene faculty member and a biostatistician.
Salivary flow determined by using the VAS was significantly correlated with the objective measurement of salivary volume (r = 0.70; P = .006). Number of teeth decayed was significantly correlated with VAS caries (r = 0.83; P < .001). In addition, VAS items not expected to change over time were highly correlated on different days (caries, r = 0.90, P < .001; stain, r = 0.94, P < .001). This assessment tool provided greater discrimination than categorical scoring systems do; data collectors were extensively trained and were periodically retested to maintain interrater reliabilities greater than 0.90.
Cultures of oral specimens were evaluated microscopically (Gram stain) and semiquantitatively. Each culture was scored on a 3-point scale identical to the CPIS scale used to describe cultures of tracheal aspirates:
| Oral comfort care did not affect pneumonia risk.
|
After the oral assessment, a sample of saliva was collected from the sublingual pocket on the dependent side of the mouth by means of a salivette (Sarstedt Inc, Newton, NC). The salivette was centrifuged to recover the saliva, and the volume of the recovered saliva was measured. Levels of salivary immunoglobulin A and lactoferrin were determined by using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (R&D Systems, Minneapolis, Minn). Aliquots of saliva samples were stored at 70°C until assay. All assays were performed in triplicate.
Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia. Development of VAP was determined by using the CPIS.2325 With the CPIS, points are assigned to 6 easily obtained variables:
Points for each variable of the CPIS are summed, yielding a total CPIS (range 012), which provides a range of scores for data analysis. Although some investigators26,27 have used the CPIS as a dichotomous measure of VAP (CPIS = 6 indicates pneumonia, and CPIS <6 indicates no pneumonia), other investigators12,23,28 have used the entire range of scores to describe the clinical development and progression of pulmonary infection over time. We used the full range of scores to describe the risk of VAP.
Several other risk factors may contribute to the development of VAP. Descriptive data related to these risk factors also were collected, including demographics and severity of illness as determined by scores on the Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation (APACHE) II. Demographic data included sex, race, age, previous use of antibiotics, reason for intubation, type of intubation, intubation process, and reason for admission to the ICU.
Procedure
For each patient, if inclusion criteria were met, the study was explained to the patients legally authorized representative and consent was obtained. Data were collected from time of enrollment in the study through day 7 of intubation or until extubation. Oral health status and CPIS were determined 3 times during the study: within 24 hours of intubation (baseline, at time of enrollment), at 72 to 96 hours after intubation (during day 4 of intubation, corresponding to the definition of early-onset VAP29), and at 144 to 168 hours after intubation (during day 7 of intubation, corresponding to late-onset VAP29). Data related to other risk factors for VAP were collected daily and included information on ventilator support, enteral nutrition, and selected medications.
| As salivary volume decreased, risk of pneumonia increased.
|
Data Analysis
Descriptive statistics were used to summarize the characteristics of the study population; percentages were calculated for discrete variables and means and SDs for continuous variables. A general forward selection multiple regression analysis was used to model the relationship between oral health status and CPIS at day 4. Day 4 was chosen because the sample size at day 7 was small because of loss of patients (extubation or death). Variables examined included baseline CPIS, oral assessment scores, salivary volume, salivary immunoglobulin A, salivary lactoferrin, and demographic variables. The final model had the highest overall analysis of variance F ratio (F6,21 = 4.86, P = .006) and adjusted R2 (R2adj = 0.52). Model parameters are presented in Table 1
. Finally, model assumptions were checked by examining the residual by predicted plot, the normal quantile plot of the residuals, and regression diagnostics.
|
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
The risk of VAP as evidenced by mean CPIS consistently increased over time (Table 3
). Of the 31 patients with complete data through day 4, a total of 8 (26%) had a score of 6 or higher on the CPIS.
|
The complex relationship between day 4 CPIS and plaque, APACHE II scores, and baseline CPIS was evaluated by using contour plots. In order to generate the plots, plaque scores were collapsed into 3 categories: low (cleanest teeth), moderate, and high (most plaque). Figure 1
shows the relationship of these categories to day 4 CPIS across a range of APACHE II scores for patients who did not have pneumonia at baseline (CPIS <5). The contour plots are keyed so that the darkest areas correspond to a day 4 CPIS of 6 or greater (indicating pneumonia). CPIS on day 4 increased as the APACHE II score increased.
|
| In the most critically ill, increases in dental plaque increased the risk of pneumonia.
|
In patients with the cleanest teeth (Figure 1
, left panel), higher baseline CPIS was predictive of a slight decrease in day 4 CPIS for patients whose APACHE II scores were greater than 26. However, for patients whose APACHE II scores were less than 26, increases in baseline CPIS were predictive of increased day 4 CPIS. Similar patterns held for patients with moderate plaque (Figure 1
, middle panel) and the most plaque (Figure 1
, right panel), although the breakpoint for APACHE II score was 23 in the patients with moderate plaque and 21 in the patients with the most plaque.
In all categories, when APACHE II and baseline CPIS were held constant, plaque increases were associated with increased day 4 CPIS. The model indicates that increased plaque was most predictive of pneumonia in patients with high APACHE scores and lower baseline CPIS.
Changes in Oral Health Status During the First 7 Days of Intubation
Data related to oral health status on study days 1 (baseline), 4, and 7 are presented in Tables 3
and 4
. Salivary volume decreased over time, with significant differences between day 1 and day 7 (t test, P = .003). Dental plaque consistently increased over time, although the differences were not significant. Baseline plaque score was highly correlated with day 4 plaque score (r = 0.65, P < .001). Baseline salivary lactoferrin was positively correlated with day 4 plaque score (P = .01). Other correlations were not significant.
|
|
statistic. The analysis revealed significant agreement on all 3 study days between oral swab score and tracheal aspirate score (day 1, P = .02; day 4, P < .001; day 7, P = .008). | Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The study sample was a diverse group, with African Americans and women well represented. Severity of illness was appropriate for a large urban medical center, and the VAP rate was similar to the rate reported in the literature.30 Interestingly, the number of decayed, missing, and filled teeth in our sample is similar to that reported by Fourrier et al31 (mean 6, SD 8) in a sample of patients in Europe.
Others have examined dental plaque in ICU patients, but we focused exclusively on patients receiving mechanical ventilation, restricted the study to the first 7 days of intubation, and included oral health status parameters other than plaque. In a study by Scannapieco et al,14 a total of 34 patients in a medical respiratory ICU had mean plaque scores significantly greater than those of outpatients in a preventive dentistry clinic. Fourrier et al31 found an increase over time in dental plaque on premolar teeth in 15 ICU patients examined on study days 0 and 5. El-Solh et al32 examined dental plaque in 49 elderly long-term care residents at the time of admission to the ICU and found that dental plaque was worse in those who were subsequently colonized with respiratory pathogens than in those who were not colonized. Scannapieco et al14 did not examine the relationships between VAP and dental plaque and oral colonization. Fourrier et al31 found that colonization of dental plaque with potential pathogens was significantly associated with subsequent nosocomial infections (not limited to VAP).
| Good salivary flow enhances the removal of oral organisms, reducing pneumonia.
|
Our data support a link between increases in dental plaque and the development of VAP. The relationship was not straightforward but was influenced by interactions among dental plaque, baseline severity of illness, and baseline pulmonary infection status. The effect of increased plaque was most predictive of pneumonia in patients with high APACHE scores and lower baseline CPIS. The effect of oral care interventions on VAP has not been shown, but as plaque-reduction interventions are tested, patients who have the highest severity of illness but do not yet have signs of pulmonary infection might derive the most benefit. The differential benefits of plaque reduction in particular subgroups of patients require additional investigation.
Association of plaque scores and risk for VAP may be due to the potential for dental plaque to harbor pathogens responsible for VAP in the microbially rich biofilm. Scannapieco et al,14 Fourrier et al,31 and El-Solh et al32 all found potential VAP pathogens, including S aureus and P aeruginosa, in the oral cavities of ICU patients. We also cultured these organisms from oral and tracheal secretions. Potential pathogens were present in oral specimens at the same time as or before the appearance of the pathogens in tracheal secretions, similar to the findings in elderly subjects reported by El-Solh et al.32
We observed that lower baseline salivary volumes were associated with increased day 4 CPIS (and risk of VAP). Because of the importance of salivary flow in mechanical removal of oral organisms and in distribution of salivary immune components throughout the oral cavity,1518 this finding was not surprising. Although our examination was restricted to the first 7 days of ventilation, the reduction in salivary volume over time might contribute to increases in risk for VAP beyond the period we studied. Many of the medications given to critically ill patients (including benzodiazepines, haloperidol, and meperidine) can affect salivary volume. Methods of increasing oral mucosal hydration merit investigation.
Our data further indicate that levels of innate and specific immune components in the mouth, particularly salivary lactoferrin and immunoglobulin A, do change during critical illness. The role of salivary immune factors has not been thoroughly investigated and might provide additional insights into risk factors for VAP.
We developed an oral VAS to address difficulties with previous bedside oral evaluation tools. Our assessment tool has tested reliability and validity, includes multiple parameters of oral health status, and is designed to evaluate those parameters as continuous measures. Some of the individual items on the VAS (eg, caries) are not expected to change during hospitalization; these items provide a mechanism for ongoing evaluation of interrater reliability in individual patients or groups of patients. Of note, we were able to maintain a greater than 0.90 interrater reliability throughout the study with minimal training.
Dental plaque and salivary volume can be determined by bedside clinicians and are associated with risk for VAP. These factors are theoretically amenable to alteration by nursing interventions, although oral care interventions in adults receiving mechanical ventilation have not been tested extensively. However, current oral care is focused on comfort rather on plaque removal or stimulation of salivary flow. We are testing the effect of specific oral care interventions on removal of plaque and reduction of the incidence of VAP in patients in a surgical, medical, and neuroscience ICU.
| Optimal oral care should focus on plaque removal and stimulation of salivary flow.
|
Oral care interventions that prevent the accumulation of plaque and stimulate local oral immunity during the early period of hospitalization might reduce development of VAP. These relationships require further examination and might guide the development of effective nursing care interventions for prevention of VAP.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
To purchase electronic or print reprints, contact The InnoVision Group, 101 Columbia, Aliso Viejo, CA 92656. Phone, (800) 809-2273 or (949) 362-2050 (ext 532); fax, (949) 362-2049; e-mail, reprints{at}aacn.org.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
P. K. Kutty, B. Moody, J. S. Gullion, M. Zervos, M. Ajluni, R. Washburn, R. Sanderson, M. A. Kainer, T. A. Powell, C. F. Clarke, et al. Multistate Outbreak of Burkholderia cenocepacia Colonization and Infection Associated With the Use of Intrinsically Contaminated Alcohol-Free Mouthwash Chest, December 1, 2007; 132(6): 1825 - 1831. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. M. Berry, P. M. Davidson, J. Masters, and K. Rolls Systematic Literature Review of Oral Hygiene Practices for Intensive Care Patients Receiving Mechanical Ventilation Am. J. Crit. Care., November 1, 2007; 16(6): 552 - 562. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |